What history tells us about investing through a property market downturn

When property markets soften, the instinct for many buyers is to wait. To hold back until the bottom is clear, the outlook is certain and the path forward feels safer. History suggests that instinct, however understandable, comes at a cost.

Domain’s recent analysis of Australian housing cycles found that, since the mid-1990s, the market has recorded eight distinct downturns. Not one went without a recovery. In every completed cycle, prices not only recovered the ground lost – they grew to new highs.

What the data shows

Across all eight completed cycles, the average upswing lasted 2.8 years and delivered average price growth of 32.3%. The average downturn lasted just eight months, with an average peak-to-trough decline of 2.9%. The pattern is consistent: upswings outrun downturns in both duration and size, every time.

Even the deepest downturn on record, the 2017-19 cycle, which saw a peak-to-trough decline of 8.5% nationally, was followed by a recovery that more than erased the losses. Importantly, Domain noted the cause of that cycle was specific: APRA tightened lending standards and curtailed investor loans. This was a regulatory intervention with a defined endpoint and not a sign of structural weakness in the market.

The current cycle, with Domain forecasting Sydney house prices could ease by up to 7% through to June 2027, sits within the historical range.

KPMG’s August 2026 outlook took a similar view, forecasting Sydney house prices to fall 4.4% over 2026 before recovering 3.6% in 2027. KPMG described the expected trajectory as V-shaped. NAB’s latest Housing Monitor was more cautious, forecasting combined capital prices to fall around 5% over 2026, with Sydney and Melbourne leading declines of approximately 10% from peak to trough.

However, even on NAB’s more conservative numbers, the forecast correction remains well within the bounds of what previous cycles have delivered, and well short of the 22.8% fall that would be needed for combined capital prices to return to the March 2023 trough. No major forecaster is projecting a decline of that magnitude.

Experienced investors look long-term

Investors who have operated through multiple cycles tend to look past short-term price movements and focus instead on the conditions that drive long-term demand. In Sydney and across most capitals, those conditions remain intact: a housing supply shortfall, sustained population growth and rental vacancy rates near historic lows.

These structural factors are not resolved by a period of softer prices. If anything, constrained supply and continued population growth mean underlying demand keeps building. Most often, what changed the trajectory was the interest rate cycle turning, and on that front the outlook is becoming clearer. All four major banks now forecast rate cuts beginning in 2027: The Commonwealth Bank expects the first cut in May, NAB in June and ANZ in the second half of 2027. Westpac is also predicting no further changes in 2026.

When cuts arrive, borrowing capacity lifts, confidence tends to return and buyers who have been sitting on the sidelines will probably move quickly. The data from previous cycles suggests that waiting for a clear recovery signal can mean missing the conditions that preceded it.

A slower market can create opportunity

Market slowdowns tend to shift the balance of power. Fewer competing buyers, longer days on market and more motivated vendors are conditions that don’t often exist at the peak of a growth cycle, particularly in tightly held markets like Sydney’s blue-chip suburbs, where quality stock rarely changes hands.

For well-prepared buyers with clear criteria and access to finance, a period of softer sentiment can be a good time to consider assets that would otherwise attract a lot of competition. The key is being positioned to act with your finance assessed, strategy clear and a long enough time horizon to hold through the remainder of the current cycle and into the next.

Menu